{"assessment":{"band":"Keystone","factor_identity":{"basis":"approved shared identity","growth_habit_source":"USDA PLANTS","name_used":"Cirsium muticum"},"factor_scopes":{"bees":"Southeastern North America","birds":"North America","caterpillars":"Host genera of native Lepidoptera with established Kentucky range; association and range overlap, not confirmed local feeding.","specialists":"Eastern North America","structure":"USDA species growth habit where matched; otherwise sourced atlas growth habit"},"factors":{"applied_insect_credit":0,"baseline_score":87,"composite":0.889,"insect_support":{"credit":0,"groups":{"ants":{"credit":0,"flower_visits":[],"label":"Ants","recorded_name_count":null,"recorded_names":[],"seed_interactions":[],"status":"unknown"},"beetles":{"credit":0,"flower_visits":[],"label":"Beetles","recorded_name_count":null,"recorded_names":[],"seed_interactions":[],"status":"unknown"},"flies":{"credit":0,"flower_visits":[],"label":"Flies","recorded_name_count":null,"recorded_names":[],"seed_interactions":[],"status":"unknown"},"moths_butterflies":{"credit":0,"flower_visits":[],"label":"Adult butterflies / moths","recorded_name_count":null,"recorded_names":[],"seed_interactions":[],"status":"unknown"},"other_hymenoptera":{"credit":0,"flower_visits":[],"label":"Other wasps","recorded_name_count":null,"recorded_names":[],"seed_interactions":[],"status":"unknown"},"other_insects":{"credit":0,"flower_visits":[],"label":"Other insects","recorded_name_count":null,"recorded_names":[],"seed_interactions":[],"status":"unknown"}},"interpretation":"One provisional point per additional documented insect group, capped at five. Flower visits are a resource-use proxy, not confirmed feeding or pollination. Missing evidence is unknown. Study volume and repeated records earn no extra credit.","maximum_credit":5,"version":"insect-support-1"},"pct":{"bees":0.9869727047146402,"birds":0.8722084367245657,"caterpillars":0.9050868486352357,"specialists":0.9838709677419355,"structure":0.5},"rank_pct":0.911,"raw":{"bees":60,"birds":6,"caterpillars":32,"genus_used":["Cirsium","Carduus"],"specialists":12,"structure":["Forb/herb"]}},"fit_score":null,"native_basis":"native_inferred","rarity_adjustment":0,"rarity_policy":"Conservation status is displayed separately and never changes ecological scores, including when unranked.","reason":"Calculated with the shared rules using Kentucky host-range and shared ecological evidence.","reference":"NC native reference cohort, method 0.6.4; not a Kentucky percentile","score":87,"scoring_inputs":{"harm_penalty":0,"invasive":false,"invasive_rank":null,"native":true,"state_rank":"S4S5"},"source_ids":["lep_ky","globi","bigbee","avian","usdahabit","robertson","antseed"],"status":"scored_provisional","version":"shared-0.6.5"},"condition_evidence":{"light":{"evidence_id":"fact:143628ecd31514f3a2605f12a4e6e3ccf0148685394c24b6365dec704ef99494","levels":[4],"policy":"selected-condition-categories-1","range":[4,4],"scope":{"kind":"unspecified"},"semantics":"source_light_categories_preserved_without_hour_conversion","source_field":"light","source_label":"NC Extension Plant Toolbox","source_url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cirsium-muticum/","status":"mapped_selected_fact"},"moisture":{"evidence_id":"fact:8979b1785e64d448b70fca2b0b2d8b7c1e07adaf9a2301310865f44b0e4b9d99","levels":[3],"policy":"selected-condition-categories-1","range":[3,3],"scope":{"kind":"unspecified"},"semantics":"source_drainage_or_moisture_categories_preserved","source_field":"moisture_categories","source_label":"NC Extension Plant Toolbox","source_url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cirsium-muticum/","status":"mapped_selected_fact"}},"evidence":{"fit_score":null,"growth_habit":["Forb/herb"],"invasive_status":{"status":"unresolved"},"native_status":{"status":"native_inferred"},"occurrence":{"county_fips":["21061","21071","21095","21109","21129","21147","21165","21195","21197"],"meaning":"Recorded occurrence; not a county native-range assertion"},"quercus_score":null,"regional":{"county_fips":["21061","21071","21095","21109","21129","21147","21165","21195","21197"],"growth_habit":"forb","growth_habit_source":"tnky_atlas","invasive":null,"invasive_evidence":[],"invasive_rank":null,"native":true,"native_evidence":[{"claim":"native","matched_name":"Cirsium muticum","scope":"TN-KY","source":"tnky_atlas","url":"https://tennessee-kentucky.plantatlas.usf.edu/plant/species/3118"},{"claim":"native","matched_name":"Cirsium muticum","scope":"L48","source":"usda","text":"CAN:N L48:N SPM:N","url":"https://plants.usda.gov/"},{"claim":"native","matched_name":"Cirsium muticum","scope":"NC","source":"nc_flora","url":"https://auth1.dpr.ncparks.gov/flora/"},{"claim":"native","matched_name":"Carduus muticus","scope":"NC","source":"nc_flora","url":"https://auth1.dpr.ncparks.gov/flora/"}],"native_status":"native_inferred","source_ids":["tnky:3118"],"source_name":"Cirsium muticum","source_refs":["KY-county-21071.json","KY-county-21095.json","KY-county-21109.json","KY-county-21129.json","KY-county-21147.json","KY-county-21165.json","KY-county-21195.json","KY-county-21197.json","sernec_county"],"source_url":"https://tennessee-kentucky.plantatlas.usf.edu/plant/species/3118","state_rank":"S4S5"},"source_refs":["KY-county-21071.json","KY-county-21095.json","KY-county-21109.json","KY-county-21129.json","KY-county-21147.json","KY-county-21165.json","KY-county-21195.json","KY-county-21197.json","sernec_county"],"source_url":"https://tennessee-kentucky.plantatlas.usf.edu/plant/species/3118","state_rank":{"value":"S4S5"}},"fit_inputs":{"light":[4,4],"moisture":[3,3],"ph":null},"fit_provenance":{"counties":"USDA PLANTS: recorded in 19 NC counties","light":"NC Extension Plant Toolbox","moisture":"NC Extension Plant Toolbox"},"fit_record":{"band":"Keystone","condition_evidence":{"light":{"evidence_id":"fact:143628ecd31514f3a2605f12a4e6e3ccf0148685394c24b6365dec704ef99494","levels":[4],"policy":"selected-condition-categories-1","range":[4,4],"scope":{"kind":"unspecified"},"semantics":"source_light_categories_preserved_without_hour_conversion","source_field":"light","source_label":"NC Extension Plant Toolbox","source_url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cirsium-muticum/","status":"mapped_selected_fact"},"moisture":{"evidence_id":"fact:8979b1785e64d448b70fca2b0b2d8b7c1e07adaf9a2301310865f44b0e4b9d99","levels":[3],"policy":"selected-condition-categories-1","range":[3,3],"scope":{"kind":"unspecified"},"semantics":"source_drainage_or_moisture_categories_preserved","source_field":"moisture_categories","source_label":"NC Extension Plant Toolbox","source_url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cirsium-muticum/","status":"mapped_selected_fact"}},"county_fips":["21061","21071","21095","21109","21129","21147","21165","21195","21197","37011","37021","37023","37039","37043","37049","37077","37087","37089","37097","37099","37115","37129","37135","37157","37159","37171","37175","37183","47009","47019","47021","47029","47031","47043","47049","47055","47061","47091","47101","47119","47139","47149","47177","47187","47189"],"fit_inputs":{"light":[4,4],"moisture":[3,3],"ph":null},"fit_note":"Shared sunlight, moisture and pH calculation; county geography is an additional layer. Missing source traits remain unknown.","fit_provenance":{"counties":"USDA PLANTS: recorded in 19 NC counties","light":"NC Extension Plant Toolbox","moisture":"NC Extension Plant Toolbox"},"garden_suitability":{"default_excluded":false,"flags":[],"review_status":"not_assessed"},"invasive_rank":false,"native_eligible":true,"quercus_score":87,"state":"KY"},"garden_suitability":{"default_excluded":false,"flags":[],"review_status":"not_assessed"},"growing_observations":{"floraquest_carolinas_georgia":{"matched_name":"Cirsium muticum","retrieved":"2026-10-04T13:31:16.252589+00:00","scope":{"kind":"region","region_id":"floraquest_nc_sc_ga"},"scope_note":"Original regional ecological and identification evidence; no location-specific gardening adjustments.","source_label":"FloraQuest: Carolinas, Georgia (Southeastern Flora Team)","source_name":"Cirsium muticum","source_record_id":5887,"source_sha256":"684f6b364ff9f3023aa61ed02ae50f6f6d6d4d3bcf76847b78ab769ae0453469","source_url":"https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.emountainworks.android.southeastfieldguide","trait_evidence":[{"field":"habitat_description","source_column":"HabitatText","source_database_sha256":"684f6b364ff9f3023aa61ed02ae50f6f6d6d4d3bcf76847b78ab769ae0453469","source_record_id":5887,"source_table":"Organism","value":"Swamps, wet thickets, woodlands, seepage slopes, wet prairies, meadows."},{"field":"geographic_range_description","source_column":"Description","source_database_sha256":"684f6b364ff9f3023aa61ed02ae50f6f6d6d4d3bcf76847b78ab769ae0453469","source_record_id":5887,"source_table":"Organism","value":"Newfoundland and Labrador (Newfoundland) west to Saskatchewan, south to Delaware, North Carolina, Tennessee, and Missouri, and less commonly south to Florida, Alabama (Diamond & Woods 2009), and Texas."},{"field":"phenology_source_text","source_column":"Phenology","source_database_sha256":"684f6b364ff9f3023aa61ed02ae50f6f6d6d4d3bcf76847b78ab769ae0453469","source_record_id":5887,"source_table":"Organism","value":"Aug-Nov."},{"field":"taxonomic_synonymy","source_column":"Synonymy","source_database_sha256":"684f6b364ff9f3023aa61ed02ae50f6f6d6d4d3bcf76847b78ab769ae0453469","source_record_id":5887,"source_table":"Organism","value":"[= Ar, C, Can, Fl7, FNA19, G, GrPl, GW2, Il, K1, K4, Mi, NE, NS, NY, Oh3, Ok, Pa, POWO, S, SE1, Tat, Tn, Va, W, WH3; = Carduus muticus (Michx.) Pers. — RAB; > Cirsium muticum Michx. var. monticola Fernald — F; > Cirsium muticum Michx. var. muticum — F]"},{"field":"heliophily_index","source_column":"HIndex","source_database_sha256":"684f6b364ff9f3023aa61ed02ae50f6f6d6d4d3bcf76847b78ab769ae0453469","source_record_id":5887,"source_table":"Organism","value":6},{"field":"regional_wetland_indicators","source_column":"WetlandStatus1..5","source_database_sha256":"684f6b364ff9f3023aa61ed02ae50f6f6d6d4d3bcf76847b78ab769ae0453469","source_record_id":5887,"source_table":"Organism","value":[{"source_column":"WetlandStatus1","value":"OBL"},{"source_column":"WetlandStatus2","value":"OBL"},{"source_column":"WetlandStatus3","value":"OBL"},{"source_column":"WetlandStatus4","value":"OBL"},{"source_column":"WetlandStatus5","value":"FACW"}]},{"field":"habitat_moisture_categories","source_column":"Attr2","source_database_sha256":"684f6b364ff9f3023aa61ed02ae50f6f6d6d4d3bcf76847b78ab769ae0453469","source_record_id":5887,"source_table":"GraphicKey","value":["Moist","Wet"]},{"field":"habitat_light_categories","source_column":"Attr3","source_database_sha256":"684f6b364ff9f3023aa61ed02ae50f6f6d6d4d3bcf76847b78ab769ae0453469","source_record_id":5887,"source_table":"GraphicKey","value":["Partial shade","Full shade","Full sun"]},{"field":"graphic_key_source_attributes","source_column":"Attr0..25","source_database_sha256":"684f6b364ff9f3023aa61ed02ae50f6f6d6d4d3bcf76847b78ab769ae0453469","source_record_id":5887,"source_table":"GraphicKey","value":{"Attr0":"gr08","Attr1":"nc_cp,nc_mt,nc_pd,sc_cp,ga_cp,ga_mt,","Attr10":"en,to","Attr11":"dk","Attr13":"pi,pur","Attr14":"bris","Attr2":"Moist,Wet","Attr3":"Part,Shade,Sun","Attr3a":"y","Attr3a_subregion":"native_nc_cp:y,native_nc_mt:y,native_nc_pd:y,native_sc_cp:y,native_ga_cp:y,native_ga_mt:y,","Attr4":" 7-12","Attr5":"gl,pu","Attr6":"n","Attr7":"n,y","Attr8":"alt","Attr9":"lc"}}],"values":{"geographic_range_description":"Newfoundland and Labrador (Newfoundland) west to Saskatchewan, south to Delaware, North Carolina, Tennessee, and Missouri, and less commonly south to Florida, Alabama (Diamond & Woods 2009), and Texas.","graphic_key_source_attributes":{"Attr0":"gr08","Attr1":"nc_cp,nc_mt,nc_pd,sc_cp,ga_cp,ga_mt,","Attr10":"en,to","Attr11":"dk","Attr13":"pi,pur","Attr14":"bris","Attr2":"Moist,Wet","Attr3":"Part,Shade,Sun","Attr3a":"y","Attr3a_subregion":"native_nc_cp:y,native_nc_mt:y,native_nc_pd:y,native_sc_cp:y,native_ga_cp:y,native_ga_mt:y,","Attr4":" 7-12","Attr5":"gl,pu","Attr6":"n","Attr7":"n,y","Attr8":"alt","Attr9":"lc"},"habitat_description":"Swamps, wet thickets, woodlands, seepage slopes, wet prairies, meadows.","habitat_light_categories":["Partial shade","Full shade","Full sun"],"habitat_moisture_categories":["Moist","Wet"],"heliophily_index":6,"phenology_source_text":"Aug-Nov.","regional_wetland_indicators":[{"source_column":"WetlandStatus1","value":"OBL"},{"source_column":"WetlandStatus2","value":"OBL"},{"source_column":"WetlandStatus3","value":"OBL"},{"source_column":"WetlandStatus4","value":"OBL"},{"source_column":"WetlandStatus5","value":"FACW"}],"taxonomic_synonymy":"[= Ar, C, Can, Fl7, FNA19, G, GrPl, GW2, Il, K1, K4, Mi, NE, NS, NY, Oh3, Ok, Pa, POWO, S, SE1, Tat, Tn, Va, W, WH3; = Carduus muticus (Michx.) Pers. — RAB; > Cirsium muticum Michx. var. monticola Fernald — F; > Cirsium muticum Michx. var. muticum — F]"}},"minnesota_wildflowers":{"matched_name":"Cirsium muticum","retrieved":"2026-10-04T02:32:44.436888+00:00","scope":{"kind":"unspecified"},"scope_note":"Source-reported species characteristics; not a location-specific estimate.","source_label":"Minnesota Wildflowers","source_sha256":"ce8b66326bdb8c9b92e1a7dcff5698a8d73624c676df3f756bb42e33f9c54ae1","source_url":"https://www.minnesotawildflowers.info/flower/swamp-thistle","trait_evidence":[{"expected_source_name":"Cirsium muticum","field":"life_cycle","original_field":"life_cycle","record_id":"trait:1fbb5dbd688a986087c54799666badbf1696d1506a69e668b55eae5583ec5ea9","retrieved_at":"2026-10-04T02:32:44.436888+00:00","scope":{"kind":"unspecified"},"scope_note":"Species profile; distribution and native-status discovery filters do not establish local growing or bloom timing.","source":"minnesota","source_name":"Cirsium muticum","source_sha256":"ce8b66326bdb8c9b92e1a7dcff5698a8d73624c676df3f756bb42e33f9c54ae1","source_url":"https://www.minnesotawildflowers.info/flower/swamp-thistle","status":"eligible_fact","taxon_id":"taxon:832acba8-240e-5d4d-bfe8-92abfb40ba75","value":["biennial"]},{"expected_source_name":"Cirsium muticum","field":"height_description","original_field":"height","record_id":"trait:baea7d4bac10884d45a1b3947b6bd4184d39c1a96f67c1f587f8b6bd25042b35","retrieved_at":"2026-10-04T02:32:44.436888+00:00","scope":{"kind":"unspecified"},"scope_note":"Species profile; distribution and native-status discovery filters do not establish local growing or bloom timing.","source":"minnesota","source_name":"Cirsium muticum","source_sha256":"ce8b66326bdb8c9b92e1a7dcff5698a8d73624c676df3f756bb42e33f9c54ae1","source_url":"https://www.minnesotawildflowers.info/flower/swamp-thistle","status":"eligible_fact","taxon_id":"taxon:832acba8-240e-5d4d-bfe8-92abfb40ba75","value":{"max":8,"min":3,"unit":"feet"}}],"values":{"height_description":"3–8 feet","life_cycle":["biennial"]}},"ncsu_sitemap":{"matched_name":"Cirsium muticum","retrieved":"2026-10-04T02:33:12.651845+00:00","scope":{"kind":"unspecified"},"scope_note":"Source-reported species characteristics; not a location-specific estimate.","source_label":"NC Extension Plant Toolbox","source_sha256":"1ef0fb6586c0ff16f16eeea79af590df09cd0cdcd5d805c70a4b7e2822e37a8f","source_url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cirsium-muticum/","trait_evidence":[{"expected_source_name":"Cirsium muticum","field":"flower_color","original_field":"flower_color","record_id":"trait:29b9b7c926e08431a815abe27e513400ca24d6792872633aaf2889657c72fbda","retrieved_at":"2026-10-04T02:33:12.651845+00:00","scope":{"kind":"unspecified"},"scope_note":"Species profile; distribution and native-status discovery filters do not establish local growing or bloom timing.","source":"ncsu","source_name":"Cirsium muticum","source_sha256":"1ef0fb6586c0ff16f16eeea79af590df09cd0cdcd5d805c70a4b7e2822e37a8f","source_url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cirsium-muticum/","status":"eligible_fact","taxon_id":"taxon:832acba8-240e-5d4d-bfe8-92abfb40ba75","value":["Pink","Purple/Lavender"]},{"expected_source_name":"Cirsium muticum","field":"life_cycle","original_field":"life_cycle","record_id":"trait:54850064564496d73d7874dcda47772c1d6a6f9a4d95884d87fa2ccc06e7375d","retrieved_at":"2026-10-04T02:33:12.651845+00:00","scope":{"kind":"unspecified"},"scope_note":"Species profile; distribution and native-status discovery filters do not establish local growing or bloom timing.","source":"ncsu","source_name":"Cirsium muticum","source_sha256":"1ef0fb6586c0ff16f16eeea79af590df09cd0cdcd5d805c70a4b7e2822e37a8f","source_url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cirsium-muticum/","status":"eligible_fact","taxon_id":"taxon:832acba8-240e-5d4d-bfe8-92abfb40ba75","value":["Biennial"]},{"expected_source_name":"Cirsium muticum","field":"light","original_field":"light","record_id":"trait:65e12195ac0941b9ce62ff5e145126519ec05831c0e1494980d36ca715103d6c","retrieved_at":"2026-10-04T02:33:12.651845+00:00","scope":{"kind":"unspecified"},"scope_note":"Species profile; distribution and native-status discovery filters do not establish local growing or bloom timing.","source":"ncsu","source_name":"Cirsium muticum","source_sha256":"1ef0fb6586c0ff16f16eeea79af590df09cd0cdcd5d805c70a4b7e2822e37a8f","source_url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cirsium-muticum/","status":"eligible_fact","taxon_id":"taxon:832acba8-240e-5d4d-bfe8-92abfb40ba75","value":["Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"]},{"expected_source_name":"Cirsium muticum","field":"moisture_categories","original_field":"soil_moisture","record_id":"trait:7d7cacc81a0404ff6a9480c528b646dc2c3e01a9fefa190657c6239c01affc23","retrieved_at":"2026-10-04T02:33:12.651845+00:00","scope":{"kind":"unspecified"},"scope_note":"Species profile; distribution and native-status discovery filters do not establish local growing or bloom timing.","source":"ncsu","source_name":"Cirsium muticum","source_sha256":"1ef0fb6586c0ff16f16eeea79af590df09cd0cdcd5d805c70a4b7e2822e37a8f","source_url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cirsium-muticum/","status":"eligible_fact","taxon_id":"taxon:832acba8-240e-5d4d-bfe8-92abfb40ba75","value":["Moist","Occasionally Wet"]},{"expected_source_name":"Cirsium muticum","field":"soil_ph_categories","original_field":"soil_ph","record_id":"trait:c978d43ef660143bebc0d320567527481d5a43e29d412b80ea238533329846ff","retrieved_at":"2026-10-04T02:33:12.651845+00:00","scope":{"kind":"unspecified"},"scope_note":"Species profile; distribution and native-status discovery filters do not establish local growing or bloom timing.","source":"ncsu","source_name":"Cirsium muticum","source_sha256":"1ef0fb6586c0ff16f16eeea79af590df09cd0cdcd5d805c70a4b7e2822e37a8f","source_url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cirsium-muticum/","status":"eligible_fact","taxon_id":"taxon:832acba8-240e-5d4d-bfe8-92abfb40ba75","value":["Acid (<6.0)","Alkaline (>8.0)","Neutral (6.0-8.0)"]},{"expected_source_name":"Cirsium muticum","field":"hardiness_zones","original_field":"hardiness","record_id":"trait:e2ffe803246d4169aff58a87ebdf6a7e6bebc588017a0cb34c362034903d46e2","retrieved_at":"2026-10-04T02:33:12.651845+00:00","scope":{"kind":"unspecified"},"scope_note":"Species profile; distribution and native-status discovery filters do not establish local growing or bloom timing.","source":"ncsu","source_name":"Cirsium muticum","source_sha256":"1ef0fb6586c0ff16f16eeea79af590df09cd0cdcd5d805c70a4b7e2822e37a8f","source_url":"https://plants.ces.ncsu.edu/plants/cirsium-muticum/","status":"eligible_fact","taxon_id":"taxon:832acba8-240e-5d4d-bfe8-92abfb40ba75","value":["2a, 2b, 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b"]}],"values":{"flower_color":["Pink","Purple/Lavender"],"hardiness_zones":["2a, 2b, 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, 5a, 5b, 6a, 6b, 7a, 7b, 8a, 8b, 9a, 9b"],"life_cycle":["Biennial"],"light":["Full sun (6 or more hours of direct sunlight a day)"],"moisture_categories":["Moist","Occasionally Wet"],"soil_ph_categories":["Acid (<6.0)","Alkaline (>8.0)","Neutral (6.0-8.0)"]}},"prairie_moon_2026":{"identity_basis":"Exact scientific name; no new synonym guesses","matched_name":"Cirsium muticum","page":5,"retrieved":"2026-09-30T18:00:34.396046+00:00","row_top":84.875,"scope":"Nursery cultural guide; height in flower; moisture categories retained as printed","source_label":"Prairie Moon 2026 Cultural Guide","source_sha256":"a0653d627b36184cd6bdd39aaea55efe2c15be3899976de28f978edc07a23cf1","source_url":"https://www.prairiemoon.com/catalogs/Prairie-Moon-Nursery-Cultural-Guide-2026.pdf","values":{"bloom_season":["July","August","September","October"],"flower_color":["Pink"],"height_description":"7 feet (in flower)","light":["Full sun (6+ hours)","Part shade (3–6 hours)"],"moisture_categories":["Wet","Wet-mesic"]}},"ut_smart_yards":{"identity_basis":"Exact scientific name; no new synonym guesses","matched_name":"Cirsium muticum","modified":"2021-04-01T02:00:35+00:00","page_id":"1288","scope":"Published Tennessee growing guidance; exact cached scientific heading","source_label":"Tennessee Smart Yards","source_url":"https://tynnativeplants.wordpress.com/flowers/common-name/swamp-thistle/","values":{"height_description":"4 ft","light":["Full to part sun"],"moisture_categories":["wet to moderately wet"]}},"wildflower_center":{"matched_name":"Cirsium muticum","retrieved":"2026-10-03T21:53:23.880585+00:00","scope":{"kind":"unspecified"},"scope_note":"Source-reported species characteristics; not a location-specific estimate.","source_label":"Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center","source_sha256":"f6ef45337a5d49ef2142964e0bb681e45e38a3b45d1f37ad9083ab2b18847b8a","source_url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=CIMU","trait_evidence":[{"expected_source_name":"Cirsium muticum","field":"height_description","original_field":"height","record_id":"trait:09106351872f0e90626091efc6c0d54b0b7f49668c6fe360f8c9c7a9ffb0666d","retrieved_at":"2026-10-03T21:53:23.880585+00:00","scope":{"kind":"unspecified"},"scope_note":"Species profile; distribution and native-status discovery filters do not establish local growing or bloom timing.","source":"wildflower","source_name":"Cirsium muticum","source_sha256":"f6ef45337a5d49ef2142964e0bb681e45e38a3b45d1f37ad9083ab2b18847b8a","source_url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=CIMU","status":"eligible_fact","taxon_id":"taxon:832acba8-240e-5d4d-bfe8-92abfb40ba75","value":{"approximate":true,"kind":"upper_bound","max":8,"unit":"feet"}},{"expected_source_name":"Cirsium muticum","field":"life_cycle","original_field":"life_cycle","record_id":"trait:65e72f1bc9794f159e3c8fa3573b89e70ba6de337839c5f8319bdc1523af8956","retrieved_at":"2026-10-03T21:53:23.880585+00:00","scope":{"kind":"unspecified"},"scope_note":"Species profile; distribution and native-status discovery filters do not establish local growing or bloom timing.","source":"wildflower","source_name":"Cirsium muticum","source_sha256":"f6ef45337a5d49ef2142964e0bb681e45e38a3b45d1f37ad9083ab2b18847b8a","source_url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=CIMU","status":"eligible_fact","taxon_id":"taxon:832acba8-240e-5d4d-bfe8-92abfb40ba75","value":["Biennial"]},{"expected_source_name":"Cirsium muticum","field":"moisture_categories","original_field":"soil_moisture","record_id":"trait:9c739e63da3803a8892f188dd8bd356513ff8ac4b0ab24c1451e484e035f3469","retrieved_at":"2026-10-03T21:53:23.880585+00:00","scope":{"kind":"unspecified"},"scope_note":"Species profile; distribution and native-status discovery filters do not establish local growing or bloom timing.","source":"wildflower","source_name":"Cirsium muticum","source_sha256":"f6ef45337a5d49ef2142964e0bb681e45e38a3b45d1f37ad9083ab2b18847b8a","source_url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=CIMU","status":"eligible_fact","taxon_id":"taxon:832acba8-240e-5d4d-bfe8-92abfb40ba75","value":["Moist"]},{"expected_source_name":"Cirsium muticum","field":"flower_color","original_field":"flower_color","record_id":"trait:a0402ce3cd63e161579d272721991fe69d023f5849a9c69c3f1ff3a93657066e","retrieved_at":"2026-10-03T21:53:23.880585+00:00","scope":{"kind":"unspecified"},"scope_note":"Species profile; distribution and native-status discovery filters do not establish local growing or bloom timing.","source":"wildflower","source_name":"Cirsium muticum","source_sha256":"f6ef45337a5d49ef2142964e0bb681e45e38a3b45d1f37ad9083ab2b18847b8a","source_url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=CIMU","status":"eligible_fact","taxon_id":"taxon:832acba8-240e-5d4d-bfe8-92abfb40ba75","value":["White","Purple"]},{"expected_source_name":"Cirsium muticum","field":"light","original_field":"light","record_id":"trait:d92df9e30465829d73b33a381fd178e9975a65403c65966e1746156340aa9673","retrieved_at":"2026-10-03T21:53:23.880585+00:00","scope":{"kind":"unspecified"},"scope_note":"Species profile; distribution and native-status discovery filters do not establish local growing or bloom timing.","source":"wildflower","source_name":"Cirsium muticum","source_sha256":"f6ef45337a5d49ef2142964e0bb681e45e38a3b45d1f37ad9083ab2b18847b8a","source_url":"https://www.wildflower.org/plants/result.php?id_plant=CIMU","status":"eligible_fact","taxon_id":"taxon:832acba8-240e-5d4d-bfe8-92abfb40ba75","value":["Sun"]}],"values":{"flower_color":["White","Purple"],"height_description":"Up to about 8 feet","life_cycle":["Biennial"],"light":["Sun"],"moisture_categories":["Moist"]}}},"light_range":["full sun","full sun"],"light_source":"NC Extension Plant Toolbox","native_synthesis":{"claims":[{"claim":"native","matched_name":"Cirsium muticum","scope":"TN-KY","source":"tnky_atlas","url":"https://tennessee-kentucky.plantatlas.usf.edu/plant/species/3118"},{"claim":"native","matched_name":"Cirsium muticum","scope":"L48","source":"usda","text":"CAN:N L48:N SPM:N","url":"https://plants.usda.gov/"},{"claim":"native","matched_name":"Cirsium muticum","scope":"NC","source":"nc_flora","url":"https://auth1.dpr.ncparks.gov/flora/"},{"claim":"native","matched_name":"Carduus muticus","scope":"NC","source":"nc_flora","url":"https://auth1.dpr.ncparks.gov/flora/"}],"county_native_range":"unresolved","explanation":"Source scopes are preserved. State occurrence alone does not establish nativity; combined regional evidence is labeled estimated.","label":"Native to Kentucky (estimated from combined sources)","rule":"southeast-native-synthesis-1","status":"native_inferred"},"source_name":"Cirsium muticum","taxon_id":"taxon:832acba8-240e-5d4d-bfe8-92abfb40ba75","revision":"publish:5809c037-0e9a-430a-8008-5ab6f69800c0","photos":[{"id":"cirsium-muticum-17631401","src":"/api/photos/image/65e534d1f205f62ff1c401e82c917c4f739d3d9a8995e6a4a77743c37cac04ea.jpg","view":"bloom","alt":"Cirsium muticum — bloom photograph","width":960,"height":1280,"artist":"Superior National Forest","license":"CC BY 2.0","license_url":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0","source_url":"https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Cirsium_muticum.jpg","changes":"Wikimedia thumbnail; no crop or retouching"}]}